Skip to main content

How low can you go ? speech by Andy Haldane BoE Chief Economist


[William Thomson, 1st Baron Kelvin]



In a speech to the Portadown Chamber of Commerce in Northern Ireland Andy Haldane, the Bank of England’s Chief Economist, discusses the future of money and the future of monetary policy.

Andy first considers the need for central bankers to explore ways of conducting monetary policy at the zero lower bound. He then turns to the outlook for the UK economy today, setting out his stance that “the case for raising UK interest rates in the current environment is… some way from being made.”


“Following the global financial crisis, short-term interest rates fell sharply in a great many countries”.

Monetary policy makers must now consider how to deal with the risk that global rates remain persistently lower.


Source: King and Low (2014); Bank Calculations.

Note: The ‘World’ real rate is taken from King and Low (2014) and shows the average 10-year yield of inflation-linked bonds in the G7 countries (excluding Italy) over the period 1985-2013. It has been extended back to the 1980s (dotted line) using a simple regression linking it to movements in UK 10-year nominal yields and RPI inflation. The red and blue lines are calculated as the nominal yield on 10-year sovereign bonds minus 1-year ahead inflation expectations from Consensus Economies. Figures have been GDP-weighted together for 20 advanced economies and 17 emerging markets.

“Central banks may then need to think imaginatively about how to deal on a more durable basis with the technological constraint imposed by the zero lower bound on interest rates.”



Source: Barclays, Bloomberg and Bank calculations.
Note: (a) Derived from index-linked gilts referenced to RPI. (b) Barclays Basix survey. Data do not refer to a specific inflation index. (c) Bank of England Survey of External Forecasters. Financial markets data to 14 September 2015, survey data are to 2015Q3.


Andy explores three possible solutions. The first “would simply be to revise upwards inflation targets” giving central banks extra interest rate “wiggle room”. However, any such increase could have a negative effect on inflation expectations which could in turn “be damaging to macro-economic stability.” It would also be inconsistent with the public’s preferences.
Alternatively, unconventional monetary policy tools could be made permanent. “That might mean accommodating QE as part of the monetary policy armoury during normal as well as crisis times”. Although QE does appear to have been “reasonably powerful”, it is highly state contingent and its impacts are uncertain; a permanent version could blur the line between fiscal and monetary policy and potentially undermine central bank independence; and, international spill-over effects could have consequences for the exercise of national monetary policy in other countries.
The third and final option for dealing with the ZLB would be charging a negative interest rate on currency,most probably through a state-issued digital currency. “This would preserve the social convention of a state-issued unit of account and medium of exchange… But it would allow negative interest rates to be levied on currency easily and speedily”. Many questions remain about how this would work in practice and whether the public would support the change, but it is an area worthy of further research as it would represent a “great technological leap forward” for money and monetary policy.

Andy ends by turning to the issue of monetary policy today. He explains his view of recent events in Greece and China as “the latest leg of what might be called a three-part crisis trilogy”. While “it is simply too soon to tell how potent contagion from EMEs [emerging market economies] to the world economy will be” few of the headwinds to these economies “seem likely to abate quickly”.
“Against these negative external forces are weighing solid UK domestic demand forces.” But “while the UK’s recovery remains on track, there are straws in the wind to suggest slowing growth into the second half of the year” such as softening employment and surveys suggesting slowing output growth.

In addition, headline UK consumer price inflation is still close to zero and “Even after stripping out food and energy prices… the Bank’s range of core inflation measures average around 1%” leading Andy to state that he is not as confident as he would like “that one percentage point of additional nominal pick-up will be forthcoming over the next two years.”

He concludes “were the downside risks I have discussed to materialise, there could be a need to loosen rather than tighten the monetary reins as a next step to support UK growth and return inflation to target.”

The Andy's full speech with more charts and info-graphics can be down loaded here




The future of cash - Quarterly Bulletin article



Further Reading


FHFA Adopts Final Rule on 2015-2017 Housing Goals for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

UK inflation slips back to zero BoE rate hike months away

FHFA Adopts Final Rule on 2015-2017 Housing Goals for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

Senate votes to suspend Fannie Mae Freddie Mac CEO pay

Mortgage Lenders and Administrators statistics Bank of England Sept 2015

Right to Buy Homes Sales: April to June 2015 England Update

House price inflation gathers pace as market conditions tighten further August 2015 update

Help to Buy, has helped nearly 120,000 people achieve their aspiration of buying a new home since it was created, latest figures reveal

When building more homes isn't enough in the UK

UK Housing Price Index JULY 2015

Help to Buy >Equity Loan scheme > Help to Buy NewBuy statistics Data to 30 June 2015 England

What Jeremy Corbyn's leadership victory may mean for housing policy in the UK

Newly Elected Labour Candidate, for Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, outlines his Housing Policies

Marie's Question >Jeremy Corbyn The New Labour Leader
takes his seat in the Houses of Parliament

Weak UK construction data adds to signs of cooling growth

Would a robot replace an estate agent in the future ?

The number of real estate agency UK jobs slowing at a dramatic rate 5000 decline ( 15 year data ) factors

emoov is really moving !

property ecommerce is booming !

The Perfect Property Storm?

Emoov.co.uk to enter US property market Could you sell your home without a real estate agent?

Iconic Building Lincoln House [Former Maharajah Palace and US embassy ] sold to business tycoon $113m

OntheMarket.com complaints continue to The Competition and Markets Authority

zoopla.co.uk and rightmove.co.uk primelocation.com subscriptions can be justified

House Prices in UK Overview