Skip to main content

A question from Matthew > PMQs Jeremy Corbyn MP vs The Prime Minister David Cameron


Jeremy Corbyn:

The reality is that 3 million low and middle-income families will be worse off as a result of the tax credit changes. If the Prime Minister wants to change his mind on tax credits, he is very welcome to do so. He will have an opportunity at next week’s Opposition day debate, which is on this very subject. I am sure that he will want to take part in that debate and explain why it is such a good idea to make so many people so much worse off.


I have had 3,500 questions on housing in the past few days. I have a question from Matthew. [Interruption.] This might be funny to some Members, but it is not funny to Matthew or to many others. Matthew says:

“I live in a private rented house in London with three other people. Despite earning a salary well over the median wage, buying even the cheapest of properties will be well beyond my reach for years.”



Does the Prime Minister really believe that £450,000 is an affordable price for a new home for someone on an average income to try to aspire to?

The Prime Minister:


The hon. Gentleman is absolutely right to raise the issue of housing, particularly the affordability of housing in London. I say to Matthew that we are doing everything we can to get councils to build more houses, particularly affordable houses that he can buy. The hon. Gentleman quotes the figure of £450,000, but what we are saying is that that should be the upper limit for a starter home in London. We want to see starter homes in London built at £150,000 and £200,000, so that people like Matthew can stop renting and start buying. What have we done for people like Matthew? We have introduced Help to Buy, so for the first time we are helping people to get their deposit together so that they can buy a new home. We are also giving people like Matthew the right to buy their housing association home. [Interruption.] That is interesting. We hear groans from the Labour party, but the entire housing association movement is now backing our plan and telling people that they will be able to buy their home. I say to the hon. Gentleman: let us work together and get London building to get prices down so that people like Matthew can afford to buy a home of their own.

Jeremy Corbyn:

May I bring the Prime Minister back to reality? The past five years have seen a low level of house building—fewer than half the new buildings that are needed have been built—rapidly rising rents; rising homelessness; and a higher housing benefit bill. Even his friends at the CBI say we need to build at least 240,000 homes per year. Will he now address the problem that local authorities face in accessing funds to undertake the necessary and essential building of council housing? The Government appear to have a growing obsession with selling off publicly owned properties rather than building homes for people who desperately need them so that children can grow up in a safe and secure environment, which is what we all want for all of our children.

The Prime Minister:

Let me deal with all the hon. Gentleman’s points in turn. First, now that the housing association movement is backing the Right to Buy scheme, there will be up to a million extra homeowners, with the money going back into building more homes. Secondly, over the past five years that I have been Prime Minister, we have built more council homes than the previous Labour Government built in 13 years. [Interruption.] That is a bit of reality that the hon. Gentleman might want to digest. The most important point is that if we want to build homes, we need a strong and stable economy. We will not have a strong and stable economy if we adopt the new Labour position, which is borrowing money for ever. I urge Opposition Members who believe in a strong economy, paying down our deficit, and ensuring that we deliver for working people to join us in the Lobby tonight.

Jeremy Corbyn:

It would be very nice if the Prime Minister actually answered the question I asked. [Interruption.]

Mr Speaker:

Order. These proceedings should be conducted in a seemly way, and chuntering from a sedentary position, from either Front Bench, is not helpful. Members must remain calm. Be as good as you can be.

Jeremy Corbyn:


Thank you, Mr Speaker. I am totally calm, I assure you, and I do not intend to engage in any chuntering.


The question I put to the Prime Minister was this: what is he doing to allow local authorities to build the homes that are necessary for people who have no opportunity to buy and who cannot afford to remain in the private rented sector? I realise that this might be complicated, so I would be very happy for him to write to me about it. We could then share the letter with others.








Meanwhile Outside houses of parliament Housing Minster Brandon Lewis commented to reporters 



Brandon Lewis, the Minister for Housing and Planning told the BBC Labour's economic policy is in chaos:

He said the chancellor was making it very clear this is a government that will "fix the roof while the sun is shining" and this government believed in economic security.

So that people have an economic future they can look forward to for themselves and their children and their families in the future. To do that we've got to make sure that we get on top of that debt and deficit that Labour left us with."








Further Reading



Get rid of the cowboys and stabilise the lettings housing market

MPs and peers to consider energy efficiency of rented housing The All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for the Private Rented Sector (PRS)

UK house prices increased by 5.2% in the year to August 2015, unchanged from 5.2% in the year to July 2015

August house purchase lending down 9% on July but up 2% on last year

Right To Buy Homes Urgent Parliament questions with Brandon Lewis UK housing Minster

Britain Inflation and housing: joined at the hip

Zac Goldsmith: housing crisis number one priority in London – videos

Councils must produce local plans for new homes in their area by 2017 – or the government will ensure, in consultation with local people, those plans are produced for them.

Government ministers and housing association leaders have negotiated a deal to extend the right-to-buy policy

Residential sales Move up despite lack of property Stock RICS October Report

TfL could help fix London’s housing Crisis as well as our trains

Draw up plans to build more homes in two years... or we'll do it for you: PM's threat to reluctant town halls

Barriers to house building: How serious are the challenges we face?

Conservatives Conference 2015 all you need to know

UK House Price Overview

Labour conference: Sadiq Khan"I'm going to make the election a referendum on London's housing crisis"

What Jeremy Corbyn's leadership victory may mean for housing policy in the UK

London housing – a crisis for businesses too A report for Fifty Thousand Homes

10 winning ideas announced by NLA ! for Housing to help solve the London housing shortage


Newly Elected Labour Candidate, for Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, outlines his Housing Policies

property eCommerce is booming !

Taylor Wimpey CEO Peter Redfern will lead Labour Housing Redfern Review
Building Markets for the Good of People > BoE Open Forum

Bank of England concerns over Property buy-to-let boom

Government ministers and housing association leaders have negotiated a deal to extend the right-to-buy policy

How low can you go ? speech by Andy Haldane BoE Chief Economist

Three Truths about Finance - Governor of BoE - Mark Carney

Mortgage Lenders and Administrators statistics Bank of England Sept 2015

Government ministers and housing association leaders have negotiated a deal to extend the right-to-buy policy

How Nest is revolutionising smart homes with Nest Weave & Creating Most Comprehensive Developer Platform for the Home

How LG Smart Homes and nest.com are making the best use of IoT

ABB unveils intelligent voice-activated smart home system

why Uber is good for london