Skip to main content

Iain Duncan Smith resigns over planned disability benefit changes,indefensible changes,

 Britain's welfare minister Iain Duncan Smith resigned on Friday over planned reductions in welfare payments for people with disabilities unveiled by the finance minister this week.

"Changes to benefits to the disabled and the context in which they've been made are a compromise too far," he wrote in a letter following uproar against the plans, including from lawmakers in his own governing Conservative Party.

"While they are defensible in narrow terms, given the continuing deficit, they are not defensible in the way they were placed within a budget that benefits higher-earning taxpayers," said Duncan Smith, a former party leader and one of six senior ministers supporting a vote for Britain to leave the EU.

Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne told parliament on Wednesday the planned changes would cut around £1.3 billion (1.7 billion euros, $1.9 billion) a year off the bill for so-called Personal Independence Payments (PIP), which aim to help people with long-term ill health or disabilities with extra costs.

The main opposition Labour party has criticised the proposals as "appalling" and a government source on Friday said they would be "kicked into the long grass".

"We need to take time and get reforms right and that will mean looking again at these proposals," the sources.

Prime Minister David Cameron said: "We are going to discuss what we've put forward with the disability charities and others."

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn earlier said that 200,000 of the 640,000 people affected by the proposed changes would lose out altogether as a result.

Duncan Smith was one of six cabinet ministers who last month broke ranks with the rest of Cameron's government and said they would support a "Leave" vote in Britain's EU membership referendum on June 23.

He was head of the Conservative Party between 2001 and 2003.

'Reform? No, we've achieved NOTHING!' Iain Duncan Smith feels a sense of deja vu about this EU debate by IDS

For me, there is a great sense of déjà vu about this debate. Some 24 years ago, I was part of a Conservative government which battled against many of its own MPs to implement the Maastricht Treaty.

I had only just been elected to Parliament and, within days, I chose to oppose the treaty because it was clear to me that the huge extension of powers being granted to the institutions of the EU would take away our power to govern ourselves.

NO EU Souvenir ?  Orchestral Maneuvers in the dark ....
Yet at the time, John Major and his Cabinet proclaimed it to be 'game, set and match' to the UK. For we were assured that his 'incredible' deal, with its opt-outs for Britain, had turned the tide and this country's new influence in the EU would end the process of ever closer union.

The EU, we were repeatedly told had reached the high water of European federalism.
Does all this – with those words and sentiments – seem familiar?

They certainly should! For over the past few days, we have heard very similar arguments and even many of the same words used by members of this government to describe the recent negotiation with the EU.

Indeed, I even heard one of my colleagues say that last week's agreement meant that Britain should now be able to 'drive Europe in our direction'.

I hope I will be forgiven for a nostalgic shake of my head, for that was exactly what we were assured would happen 24 years ago.
However, since the Maastricht Treaty was passed, and with all those reassurances, it's just got worse and worse.
Over the past 24 years, we have witnessed three more major treaties which have brought a vast slew of new powers for the unelected Brussels Commission and the European Court of Justice.

Again and again, Britain has been outvoted on new laws demanded by the EU Commission despite ministers in Westminster being well aware that they would damage the UK's competitiveness.
Even Tony Blair's last-minute opt-out of the charter of fundamental rights has been ignored by the European Court of Justice and Britain has been sucked into its embrace against our will. From financial services to transport policy - and even welfare - it is the Commission which calls the shots and the UK suffers the consequences.

For example, take financial services, one of our biggest exporters. Just in the last few years, the UK has been outvoted on three new damaging sets of regulations which will impose a cost of billions of pounds and make the City less competitive with our global rivals.

To compound matters, when the British government challenged the decision, it was defeated in the Court of Justice, Thus, we had the addition of a national humiliation.

Take, also, the issue of national sovereignty. This isn't some vague notion – it is the foundation of all accountable democracy.

According to the dictionary definition: 'Sovereignty is understood in jurisprudence as the full right and power of a governing body to govern itself without any interference from outside.'

Of course, countries can cooperate and pool their capabilities, for example in Nato, but it is vital to recognise that they do so on the basis that they retain ultimate control of their own right to govern.

But the reason why it doesn't work with the EU is that we aren't sharing sovereignty - we have given it away.

As a result, this country is now subject to an international body of law that is supreme over our domestic laws. Britain is forced to comply with rulings of the ECJ - meaning that, in effect, it is the court that is sovereign, not our own parliament.

And now, despite all the efforts of this government, the European Commission is not prepared to see those powers rolled back.

The truth is that there is nothing proposed in last Friday's agreement that reduces or returns the enormous powers that the Commission and the Court of Justice have over our national government.

Crucially, there is also the vexed matter of who controls our borders.

We have seen during the last decade a vast number of people move to the UK for work. The scale of this migration has been overwhelming for many towns and villages around the country – yet we have been powerless to stop or restrict it.

(Left to right) John Whittingdale, Theresa Villiers, Michael Gove, Chris Grayling, Iain Duncan Smith and Priti Patel attend the launch of the Vote Leave campaign at the group's headquarters in central London
(Left to right) John Whittingdale, Theresa Villiers, Michael Gove, Chris Grayling, Iain Duncan Smith and Priti Patel attend the launch of the Vote Leave campaign at the group's headquarters in central London
Prime Minister David Cameron appears on The Andrew Marr Show yesterday morning to discuss the issues
Under EU freedom of movement rules, the UK government is not allowed to interfere with people's right to come here.

No matter what has been negotiated in Brussels this last week, Britain's border remains open to all those resident in the countries of the EU.

This has had a devastating effect on many British workers who have found themselves priced out of their own jobs market.
It is vital that we should be concerned about those who want to work hard and play by the rules but have found it difficult because of the results of this open border.

Worrying as that is, there is an even greater concern. With the borderless Shengen area in meltdown following mass migration from Turkey and Libya, security experts have raised concerns that in the near future there will be little to stop some of those migrants from such non-EU countries coming into the UK.

For, as they are fast-tracked into naturalisation in some other EU countries, there is a very real concern that they will then be able to travel to the UK under these very same freedom of movement rules.

We have already seen how the Islamic extremists who planned and carried out November's terror attacks on Paris exploited borderless Europe. Well, in the future, they could just as easily gain access to the UK.

London mayor Boris Johnson on February 21 said he would support a vote for Britain to leave the European Union in a blow for Prime Minister David Cameron ahead of the membership referendum in June
This is another reason why we must regain control over our own borders. As Europol has pointed out recently, 5,000 jihadists are said to be at large in the EU.

So, whether it is our right to set our own laws or control our own borders, Britain remains at the mercy of the EU. What's more, we don't control our own trade arrangements.

Outside the EU, we would regain that control - and be able to make our own arrangements with Japan, the US and India, nations we have strong and historic ties with.

We are told that our future now lies in a 'reformed' Europe. Sadly, history tells us that every time British governments have claimed to have changed the culture of the EU, the opposite is the case – as the Maastricht Treaty proved.

Too often, as I listen to those who want to stay in the EU, I am struck by their peculiar sense of pessimism and fear about what would happen if Britain pulled out.

Their whole case is based on the belief that this country cannot prosper and will be too weak to survive outside the EU. Even worse, I have heard some refer to the world beyond the EU as 'the dark'.

You can't think much of your country if your only reason to stay in is, 'hang on to nurse for fear of something worse.'

Yet I am an optimist about the British people. I believe passionately that this country has shown over the centuries that we write our own rules. 

Surely the UK, the fifth largest economy in the world, the third largest trading partner of Germany and the second biggest investor in the USA, with the fourth largest defence capability, has the capacity to shape its own destiny and once again be free from the shackles of a moribund European 

Replacement for I D S ?

Cameron may well be tempted to go for someone safe. Greg Clark, the bright, technocratic, consensus-seeking communities secretary would be a sound choice. He could be trust to defuse to controversy about PIP, and also get to grips with the administrative problems bedevilling universal credit. Other possibilities might include Liz Truss, the environment secretary, or Amber Rudd, the energy secretary.

Liz Truss. 

Cameron would then have to fill a vacancy at communities, or environment or energy. Will Priti Patel get her chance? As employment minister, she attends cabinet, but she is not technically cabinet rank. Putting her in the cabinet would ensure that one Brexit minister (Duncan Smith) was replaced with another, which could be useful in terms of assuring Brexit Tories that they are being treated fairly. Appointing her would also increase the cabinet’s women/minority ethnic count, always a bonus. And it would have the added advantage, perhaps, of partially silencing one of Vote Leave’s most vocal spokeswomen, because having to master a new brief would give Patel less time to fight the EU referendum battle.
Priti Patel. 
Another possible replacement for Duncan Smith would be Mark Harper, the chief whip. He is a former disability minister and was well respected by the disability lobby. Like Clark, he could also be trusted to dismantle the Tory rebellion over PIP cuts.

There is also one much bolder step that Cameron could take. Boris Johnson has been promised a cabinet job once his term as London mayor is over and, given that he has just over a month in office to go, Cameron could just about justify giving him a department to run now. The cabinet job promise was made before Johnson decided to campaign for Britain to leave the EU, and now he is certainly seen as a hostile force by Cameron. But perhaps Cameron may gamble that forcing him to get to grips with the complexities of the welfare system might help to neutralise him in some way. It’s highly unlikely, but stranger things have happened.

Finally ...

Stephen Crabb, the welsh Secretary has been appointed Work and Pensions Secretary 

former Welsh secretary Stephen Crabb

Further Reading 

UK interest rates remain balanced , though sterling hit by EU vote says BoE

David and Samantha , morning after: how Brexit divorce gets messyPropTech ,WILL change ,the global economy “beyond recognition” Rics at MIPIM conference

Starter Homes: Unlocking the Land Fund Brandon Lewis MP

Video Bank of England Mark Carney Governor quizzed on the risks of Brexit ,Sir Jon Cunliffe

Cyber Criminals Phishing Scam Email, targets rightmove property portal, inc other property sites

Locally-Led Garden Cities , Villages Towns in the United Kingdom

coca cola tango free fall on Osbornes sugar tax

Good News for Airbnb Londoners - online Micro Entreprenuers

AirBnb / online, Ebay Amazon Start Up, micro-entrepreneurs rent property income, internet ,homes

#Budget2016 George Osborne ,Stamp Duty Surcharge ,Tax, Capital Gains Tax,Housebuilding

UrPad Online new Hybrid online estate agent for Wales ,rolled out by Property Industry Experts,Caerphilly

Facebook Founder Zuckerberg settles dispute with no pay out to property developer Voskerician

new affordable housing hits record low in london data shows

Days of Chaps payment numbered ,Central banks rival Bitcoin new RSCoin super currency

what the VLOG ? London property developers, Hackney Dalston E8 Vibe illusion

technology law - eddies from property portals and now

Online estate agents, expecting sales bonaza, as sellers shun costly high street rivals

A Welsh developer of student accommodation ,plans March 2016 IPO + Wales tallest building

Help to Buy: mortgage guarantee scheme, Quarterly Statistics, March 2016

number of high street estate agents going bust up 16% , online estate agents market share up dictated by consumer not industry

NHBC NEW HOME STATISTICS ANNUAL REVIEW 2015,English Housing, Papworth Disability Trust ,Joseph Rowntree & Bungalows !

why Frank Whittle and the Saville row tailor have more in common with Warren Buffet

FT first 'Rightmove maintains grip in battle of property portals @onthemarketblog

Brick-And-Mortar Crumbling? Don't Believe It > Forbes > Leadership

Foxtons high street estate agent facing landmark claim for £2million from group of 55 landlords

Building a new deal for London: Final report of the London Housing Commission

'Kleptocracy tours' 35,000 London properties currently have unknown offshore owners.

Pop-up housing could cut cost of London’s rental market & help UK housing Crisis

Chinese hunt for property bargains in Manchester amongst others say Pinnacle Alliance Property Developer

Property pain Investigation ,service charges increasing rapidly with 30 % of firms increasing fees

UK's largest property developers accused of 'profiting' on the back of the housing crisis

Private rental prices grew by 2.7% in England

Rental prices increased in all the English regions over the year to January 2016, with rental prices increasing the most in London (3.9%).

Property pain Investigation ,service charges increasing rapidly with 30 % of firms increasing fees

Foxtons report 4% revenue increase to City, despite Prime Central London property experiencing a dead-cat bounce

Property Partner successfully completes £15.9M ($22.4M) funding round

Nested - Start Up , property online disruptor to quick sale homes ?

Building a new deal for London: Final report of the London Housing Commission

high street estate agency valuations – flattery will get you nowhere by @emoovceo

Start me up: Why London needs open workspaces for creativity, innovation and growth

Live inquiry application launch 14 th March say Land Registry Marketing Manager

LA police testing knife found on OJ Simpson property - reports

'Kleptocracy tours' 35,000 London properties currently have unknown offshore owners

UK's largest property developers accused of 'profiting' on the back of the housing crisis

Pop Up Housing a solution not just for London but the UK

estate regeneration statement GOV UK DCLG ,Lord Heseltine ,Brandon Lewis MP

Digital Mortgage service: making improvements again & again

Buy-to-let investors 'could face losses'

Uber's property footprint unmatched among San Fran Bay Area ,Tech StartUps
Guests staying with AirBnB for the super bowl top 15,000 Homes, one step closer to making estate agent obsolete , new round of funding

OnTheMarket overseas properties , Britons with holiday homes in France face paying extra 10% in tax if they sell the property following a Brexit

Guests staying with AirBnB for the super bowl top 15,000

FT first 'Rightmove maintains grip in battle of property portals @onthemarketblog

Morrisons Super Markets signs deal to sell food to Amazon online customers

Amazon eyes up UK restaurant delivery market Launches of Passion Search ,Don’t battle your passions, unleash them

David Cameron calls EU referendum for June 23 2016 Official Statement @onthemarketblog selects Birst's Cloud BI platform for data integration from all its brands and apps

Good News UK mortgage approvals hit two-year high BoE

IMF Statement: LUXEMBOURG: Concluding Statement of the 2016 Article IV Consultation Mission

Spanish house prices 2015 see rise highest rise 2007 crash , stabilisation of housing market,

No Brexit for me, why I'm staying in a reformed EU and so should you

Scotlands House prices rise and sales grow

An analysis of recent trends in the Irish rental market 2015 in Review

fourth quarter 2015: First-time buyers took out 87,100 loans to purchase homes. + house prices in UK

GeoPhy Exodus-from-EU-may-spark-correction-in-the-rental-market.html

1st of March David Cameron St David's Day message "wonderful country and a great part of the United Kingdom"

Amazon eyes up UK restaurant delivery market

Bank of England's unease over market's rate view Carney & Shafik

Morrisons Super Markets signs deal to sell food to Amazon online customers

Brick-And-Mortar Crumbling? Don't Believe It > Forbes > Leadership

Chinese authorities shut down microblogging accounts belonging to a real estate mogul

Foxtons high street estate agent facing landmark claim for £2million from group of 55 landlords

Brexit , investor, impacts on the property market overall and on aggregate consumption in the economy will be limited