Skip to main content

Hague Rejects Beijing South China Sea claims


Islands Disputed in the South China Sea | Graphiq








An international tribunal, The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) currently the site @ [12/07/2016] 1343 GMT maybe undergoing a possible DDOS attack , is an intergovernmental organization located at The Hague in the Netherlands.


The PCA is not a court, but rather an organiser of arbitral tribunals to resolve conflicts between member states ,has issued it's long-awaited ruling today in a case brought by the Philippines over China’s vast territorial claims and island-building in the South China Sea.


pictured above China has backed its claims by building a chain of landfill islands in contested waters. Some include military-grade runways



Beijing South China Sea claims have now been rejected by the highly respected international court at the hague in the Netherlands


The Court ruling from the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, Netherlands, which rejects Beijing Claims ,is the first to address competing claims and interests among a half-dozen countries fronting the South China Sea. It also comes as U.S. and Chinese warships engage in an increasingly tense game of cat and mouse in the disputed waters.




The Permanent Court of Arbitration said there was no evidence that China had historically exercised exclusive control over the waters or resources.


China has claimed virtually all of the South China Sea, a crucial waterway used for an estimated $5 trillion in annual trade.

The Philippines filed suit with the Hague tribunal in 2013, after China seized a rich fishing region known as the Scarborough Shoal. The Philippines claims that area as part of its exclusive economic zone.

The suit alleged that China’s extensive claims in the sea do not conform to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, which governs certain maritime claims and conduct.

China has refused to participate in the case or abide by today's ruling [12/07/2016 ], claiming the tribunal lacks jurisdiction.

The ruling “amounts to nothing more than a piece of paper,” former Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo told a conference in Washington, D.C., last week. “China will grip its own future on issues of territorial sovereignty and will never accept any solution imposed by a third party.”

China has backed its claims by building a chain of landfill islands  in contested waters. Some include military-grade runways, deep-water ports and extensive land facilities. China also has boosted naval activities throughout the region.





The United States says it does not take sides in individual sovereignty disputes, but has called the new islands a “Great Wall of Sand” and expressed concerns they could be used as military bases for China to restrict air and sea navigation.

China has pledged not to do that.

Nonetheless, U.S. warships have sailed within close proximity of Chinese-built islands at least three times since late 2015 in “freedom of navigation operations.” The U.S. has promised more operations.

Chinese warships have responded by tailing U.S. vessels throughout the South China Sea and ordering U.S. ships and planes to steer clear of the new islands.

In one recent case, Chinese intelligence-gathering ships followed a U.S. carrier battle group — within visual range, around the clock — for the entirety of its three-month patrol in the South China Sea.

China Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hong Lei said last week that China has “indisputable sovereignty over the South China Sea Islands and the adjacent waters,” based on “historical practices of the Chinese people and the government.”

The South China Sea is 50% larger than the Mediterranean Sea and dotted with shallow reefs, rocks and shoals. It also is believed to hold extensive deposits of minerals and other natural resources.

Taiwan, Vietnam, Brunei and Malaysia also have overlapping claims. China has said it is willing to negotiate with each claimant separately, but not together, a strategy that could give China more leverage in negotiations with its smaller neighbors.

China’s navy completed a weeklong series of exercises Monday in the disputed waters that brought together nearly 100 warships and dozens of fighter planes.

A U.S. aircraft carrier battle group and a separate U.S. “surface action group” have also been operating in the South China Sea in recent weeks.
US Aircraft Carrier USS John C Stennia in Phillpine Seas with flight formation of US Navy jets above June 18  2016  


Grant Newsham, senior research fellow at the Japan Forum for Strategic Studies in Tokyo, said The Hague tribunal’s ruling will make little difference to the realities on the ground — or  on the water.

“China will continue its successful effort to assert physical domination over the South China Sea, with the political and psychological dominance that comes with it,” Newsham said.




Further Reading 



George Osborne pledges to slash corporation tax to encourage Global business to UK a target of less than 15%


BBC Anyone ? Robert Peston ? Angela Eagle launches Labour Leadership Challenge to Jeremy Corbyn

David Cameron heard humming singing after confirming Theresa May as Prime Minister

Theresa May to become Next female UK prime minister , Andrea Leadsom resigns May to put UK Government at the service of ordinary working people

Sajid Javid to meet Indian Finance Minister Arun Jaitley and Indian Commerce and Industry Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, Post Brexit

London council early morning raid finds 17 men living in three bed terrace

UK share price up, though early post Brexit days will remain Volatile says Governer Mark Carney BoE

Andrea Leadsom Launches Conservative Leadership + BOJO SupportBank governor

Mark Carney eases rules for banks to meet Brexit challenge

Statement by the Chancellor following the EU referendum

Queen Elizabeth Speech Scottish Parliament 5th Opening staying calm and collected